I think that’s a must with the Gen 3, as the Gen 3 magazine release is very small and sharp while the Gen 4 and Gen 5 releases are a little bit better. Owners of both will argue they are the best for various reasons. Specifically, that the Gen 4 guns have finger grooves while Gen5s do not. Your Gen 4 and Gen 5 slide locks sit on the left-hand side of the gun set up for right-handed shooters only while the Gen5 slide locks are ambidextrous. I’ve purchased guns of all price points, calibers, and action types to build the best products for the market. The VP9 also comes with three swappable backstrap panels but also six (three sizes) side panels as well. Even if the reset isn't as noticable as the Glock. Harry’s Holsters Launches Redesigned Website. They both hold 17 rounds, even though the HK VP9 originally shipped with 15-round magazines. It works, but it feels like every other Glock release and depending on the variation you get, you may want to upgrade it to an aftermarket mag release. Again, the Glock Gen 3 through 5 has different slide lock variations. 25.56oz G19: L 7.28 in. Glock 19 vs VP9 vs P-10C Thread starter Prudii; Start date Sep 9, 2017; Sep 9, 2017 #1 Prudii.357 mag. Personally, I should note that I’m able to get a very solid grip with the Glock 17 vs the HK VP9 due to the blocky ergonomics. SIG 320 barrel compatibility: Our barrels have been proven to work with these 320 models only: P320 Full Size: P320 RX Full-Size P320 Nitron Full-Size. Accuracy: Again, this is purely subjective. My wife loves the VP9 and it's her bedside gun. Once you get your hand on the gun and lock it in place, the texturing does a good job of keeping your hands still on the gun. This sighting picture’s my preferred sight picture for the HK VP9 series. I will say with certain types of clothing, the grip shape on the HK VP9 vs Glock 17 will be more concealable. There are sufficient aftermarket offerings for the HK VP9, but there are a lot more for the Glock 17. The only guns that I am aware of that have moved the side panels are the HK VP9, VP9SK, and P30 series. Shooting these guns is really the test to see which one is better, and I’m going to have to say the HK VP9 seems to shoot just a little bit better — but differently — than the Glock 17. Since the HK VP9 came out in 2014, the firearms community has taken up arms (no pun intended) over which firearm is better. In my opinion, the HK having a button-style release is counterintuitive and not a great choice. Those similarities are that you’re going to feel light take-up before you reach a heavier portion and that after the trigger breaks, you’re going to have a fairly short reset. At the end of the day, it’s your gun, your preference, and this is something you can easily pick out by looking at photos. Unlike the Glock, you’re not stuck with its default setting. Magazines and Magazine Releases: I am in love with the magazine release built under the trigger guard in the VP9. Price point: The Glock 17 is around $500-600 MSRP, whereas the VP9 is around $700-750. Never listen to the guy who makes a hasty judgment after 1 magazine. HK VP9 VS Gen 5 Glock 19. Grip: For starters, the VP9 has a comfortable, ergonomic, and customizable panels that the Glock does not. That extended finger groove will likely dig into your pinky. Published by Mike on . The HK VP9 also has finger grooves, and, for myself, they work but are just slightly out of place. I like the fact that I can use multiple techniques to drop the magazine and, despite what some people say, it’s just as fast as a push-button-style release. It’s a no-brainer that the Glock 17 is the winner vs. the HK VP9 when it comes to aftermarket sights. Now Glock and HK are both great choices in the market. The HK VP9 serrations, on the other hand, are not quite as aggressive as I would like, but they still work very well. It has a light, short take-up and then you reach a wall fairly far forward in the trigger pull. Blocky ergonomics work in some cases, and this is one of them. These sights all tend to have an outdated sight picture that is not that great and you’ll probably want to replace them. Field Strip & Clean the Glock 19 Gen 5 FOR BEGINNERS. The VP9 does as well, though they are lower-profile than Glock's. The side straps and back straps could totally be changed out to your liking. Gen 4 and previous Glock pistols have finger grooves on the front of the grip housing. I think the HK just has a slight edge. The other options are 3-dot luminescent and 3-dot night sights. You also have the suppressor-height night sights for the HK VP9 2020, which are a good option if you plan to add an optic and want sights that will co-witness. Also, it is much more ergonomic than the Glock. Right off the bat, you’ll see that the biggest difference between the HK VP9 vs the Glock 17 is going to be in the frames. I know this sounds counterintuitive, but the shapelier grip on the HK VP9 will act somewhat like a revolver grip with some clothing. The Glock has a standard push-button style release and is reversible for left-handed shooters. But why I love this is that it’s more tactical! If you just lightly rub your finger over the texture, it doesn’t feel aggressive at all. Glock 17 and 19 compatibility: Our Glock 17 barrel is compatible with Gen 3 and Gen 4 Glock 17 only. A difference between the Gen 4 and Gen 5 Glock 17s involves their finger grooves. Neither are bad-looking firearms, though, and neither are exactly exquisite. And always make sure your clothing and the size of your body are appropriate for these guns. The HK VP9, SS P226, and G17/19 is up there on my list as well , Monday: Closed (Special Events Only) The Glock 17 MOS does include mounting plates, but a lot of people prefer to go with aftermarket plates anyway that fixed some engineering flaws in the Glock design. At the time I was taking my NRA Basic Pistol Course. This is much less mainstream compared to the “button on the side” for most handguns. Everyone seems to be asking the question: “Is the VP9 better?”. The HK VP9 has finger grooves with more modularity built into the grip, three sides of removal backstraps, and side panels. Trigger: The Glock comes with a decent factory trigger, though the VP9 takes the cake here with a much more superior trigger. Before, Heckler & Koch had been arming law enforcement units and militaries and security forces all over the world with guns such as the HK MP5 and UMP submachine guns, HK416 rifle, the P7 pistol, the USP and USP Compact, P2000, the HK45, and the P30.If there’s anything you need to know about the … You can also switch these out to Glock factory OEM extended slide locks, whereas with the HK, you’re stuck with what comes on the gun. This is an opinion piece, but I always aim to eliminate bias. W 1.32 in. Despite the Glock 17 offering similar capabilities for less money, the HK offers a certain amount of refinement that the Glock 17 lacks. Or, even worse, a review put together by a content writer who has never even held a gun. The Glock Gen 4 is a hybrid between the Gen 3 and Gen 5. There is no such thing as the best gun or a one-size-fits-all solution. Most of the time you spend reloading the firearm is going to be getting the new mag up and into the gun, not dropping your magazine. Different types of materials will hang to the grip differently and cause you to print while others will not. Your email address will not be published. Still, I’d much rather fork out the extra hundred-something bucks and get the newer VP9. The Glock 17 Gen 4 and Gen 5 ship with medium and large back straps as well as medium and large backstraps with beavertails, so you will receive 4 total with those generations. That’s a bitch, losing your sight picture when your magazine runs empty. There’s no competition here. I actually think the VP( trigger is better than the Pyramid trigger I have in my Glock. Both of these guns can be used for any kind of IWB or OWB carry. The VP9 was also very far from being the pistol that gave HK a name for themselves. I think newer, more inexperienced shooters will be better served with the HK VP9 while more-experienced shooters might be able to get a little slight edge on performance out of the Glock series. The HK seems to have a polish that the Glock does not. The Glock slide has a very slick finish and the serrations really aren’t that aggressive. What a great choice, new, it was $650, price went up shortly after. The VP9 has a very comfortable and customizable grip, okay sights, and a fantastic trigger. GLOCK G19 Gen 4 vs G19 Gen 5 Handgun (gen 4 not to scale, lol) The Gen 5 Glocks ship with Ameriglo GLOCK Spartan Operator night sights up from polymer sights. In praise of Glocks, let’s not forget that their parts are readily available nearly everywhere. Because of that, there’s no contest the Glock wins the aftermarket section hands-down. Cheers, It looks like a little banana thrown out on a floor, but believe it or not, it still has a pretty good grip. However, the Gen 4 and Gen 5 variations have a small grip with the ability to add extra back straps onto the gun to make it larger. H 5.41 in. There are also Gen 1 and 2 guns, but they have been out of production for a while. WORRO 16 Views Glock 19 Gen 3-Still Very Relevant. If you neglect training, it doesn’t matter how much you spend on your EDC or home defense collection. The Gen 3 texturing is very slick unless you have the RTF2 texturing, which was produced in very limited numbers. The Glock mags hold 2 more rounds in a package relatively the same size. But, sights preference is purely subjective based on its user. Heading to the range I ran a 5-circle drill. I can carry most any service pistol M9 mk25 . VP9 = 5.41 in height My P30 is 5.43 in height and I carry in IWB under a Tshirt at 3:00 Its is as High as I will go for 3:00 carry. From a size standpoint, the HK VP9 and the Glock 17 are nearly identical, including their respective weights. Most optics you’ll likely run on the gun (e.g. 23.65oz On a CCW, those numbers would be all it takes to make up my mind. Street price on the Glock 17 ranges from $500 to $620 while the HK VP9 ranges from $650 to $800. Now, when it comes to the Glocks, there’s going to be a different trigger feel for each generation, but overall they will have some similarities. The Glock was revolutionary when it was designed 30 years ago but its a different standard today for the striker polymer world. Wednesday: 11AM – 7PM Messages 555 Reaction score 614 Location Not NY anymore. Meanwhile, the blocky grip of the Glock 17 will somehow do the same thing. The HK VP9 has finger grooves with more modularity built into the grip, three sides of removal backstraps, and side panels. I’m a sucker for consumerism. AR15.COM is the world’s largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types. Look, we’ve all read them before. Overall, the quality of the HK VP9 just seems better. Our Glock 19 barrel is compatible with Gen 3, Gen 4, and Gen 5 Glock 19 and Glock 19X. I want you to walk away knowing you have the information you need to make a sound purchasing decision. Friday: 11AM – 7PM Those are easily replaced, but they also ship from the factory with AmeriGlo night sights. The slide finish and polymer on the frame seems better, but that’s not to say that the Glock is any slouch when it comes to quality. Skull Crush Inc. 12 Views Field Strip & Clean the Glock 43X FOR BEGINNERS. The Glock 17 comes in three generations: Gen 3, Gen 4, and Gen 5. Sunday 10AM – 4PM, ALICE Active Shooter Response Training Course, An Introduction to the Blog – Webmaster’s Welcome. From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm. Video De Pistola Glock 17 And Vp9 Vs Glock 17 Gen 5 is the premiere online destination for Video De Pistola Glock 17 And Vp9 Vs Glock 17 Gen 5. Both of these guns are fairly attractive firearms, but I think the HK VP9 has a slight edge. The VP9 has a much better trigger. What can I say? Price is identical. As far as feel in the hand goes, the HK VP9 definitely feels more ergonomic in spite of a lip at the bottom of the grip where one of the finger grooves extends. If you plan to carry these guns concealed, realize you will definitely need a reliable holster. Sights: Iconic or outdated? W 1.18 in. The grip on both guns is almost identical, so you’re not going to see a difference there. Your email address will not be published. I’ve heard a fair number of praises alongside grievances with this feature, though. Width: 1.26″ The Glock 17 Gen 5 The VP9 has a 15-round capacity and the Glock 17 has a 17-round capacity. With the finish on the slide not being as slick as the Glocks’, I’m going to have to give the win here to the HK. These AmeriGlo night sights have a blacked-out rear with two tritium vials, a square notch, and a front sight with a bright orange ring around a tritium vial. But if the texturing on the Glock 17 is just a little too aggressive for you, then you’ll probably prefer the HK VP9. Two of these backstrap options that ship with the gun include beavertails. These work great in both the daylight and at nighttime. If you have longer or larger hands, then the HK VP9 may not be as comfortable for you compared to the Glock 17. Either way, you’ll likely be buying a mounting plate, which will add to the expense of either pistol. I would prefer seeing this gun without the grooves, to be honest. You can now get 17-round flush-fit magazines for both guns. GLOCK Gen5 pistols are the latest examples of GLOCK'S constant pursuit of perfection. Gen 4 and Gen 5 Glock pistols have swappable backstraps, and the gun comes with three sizes. But my point is, both firearms are excellent. Comparatively, the Gen 4 texturing is a little (but not very) aggressive. If not, they’ll conceal just fine. The Glock Gen 5 trigger has a little more creep than the other variants, but it also has a very nice rolling break. If you want an optics-ready version, then you’ll still have to spend less money on the Glock. Well there are positives to both depending on what you like, cost, parts availability and that massive aftermarket for Glock. I’m going to have to give the advantage here to the Glock 17 as far as factory sight options. Gen5 pistols feature over 20 design modifications from their Gen4 predecessors, including the GLOCK Marksman Barrel, nDLC finish, ambidextrous slide stop lever, the removal of finger grooves and a flared mag-well. The slide has a little more up-and-down movement during firing, but it has less felt recoil than the Glock. Now, this optic setup doesn’t include any mounting plates, so you’ll have to purchase your mounting plate separately. It still would be my top choice. They are good guns at a similar price point and I having a hard time deciding which to get. It offers a lot of options and seems like a classier set up than a push-button style release. Again, from that wall, you build the constant buildup before the trigger breaks cleanly. The only difference between the Glock Gen 4 and Gen 5 when it comes to the frame is going to be the finger grooves: the Gen 4 has the while the Glock Gen 5 does not. Both these guns are well-made firearms. The side straps and back straps could totally be changed out to your liking. You will be surprised to see how convenient the product can be, and you may feel good realizing that this Video De Pistola Glock 17 And Vp9 Vs Glock 17 Gen 5 is amongst the best selling item on today. Skull Crush Inc. 7 Views FN FAL Battle Rifle .308 Gun Talk. You should be familiar with the tools in your arsenal. I personally really like the way a Glock shoots. The trigger on the HK VP9 is very consistent. Gen 5 Glock 19 VS HK VP9 Battle Of The Gray Compacts! A lot of people that don’t like Glock triggers normally will upgrade them to aftermarket parts, but I haven’t seen as many people doing it with the Gen 5 trigger as it just seems to be a little more shootable than the other trigger variants. This means that the Glock 19 Gen 3 … On the other hand, the Glock has multiple sight options with their famous plastic slot fillers, which you’re likely familiar with. The VP9’s grip is also larger than the grips of the 15-shot Glock 19 and Walther PPQ, which is why many people ask why HK did not increase the capacity of the weapon. VP9: L 7.34 in. Saturday 10AM – 6PM This means you’ll have to upgrade the suppressor-height sights as well to co-witness the optic. The paddle release will work just fine. So if you like aggressive texturing, you’re going to want to go with the Glock 17. Work within your comfort zone. Not everyone is willing to spend the money on that refinement, but if you are, it’ll be worth it to you. In the event of a zombie apocalypse, anti-gun legislation, or whatever your SHTF scenario is, you will find that the Glock is far superior in upkeep. The Glock Gen 3 series features a single recoil spring, as opposed to the double spring of the Gen 4 and Gen 5 series. HK comes with four different sighting options depending on the variation of the gun you get. Specifically, that the Gen 4 guns have finger grooves while Gen5s do not. Better yet, streamline past this decision-making process and get both. The side panels are unique to the HK guns. Using appendix carry the height doesn't matter as much. Tuesday: 11AM – 7PM It’s going to depend on what type of gun you prefer. Even though I was new to the pistol, I shot it nearly as well as my Glock 19. It’s a clean break, and from the reset, it goes a little more than a millimeter or two in front of the wall. The design on the HK VP9 seems better, but the slide locks themselves are recessed into the slide, so it’s not quite as easy to reach as the Glock slide locks. Gun reviews that claim to be helpful, but they’re really thinly veiled hit pieces trying to get you to buy something before you’ve even started your research. The texturing and the slide serrations really match well together and HK did a good job of being detail-oriented without being too busy. I've kinda narrowed it down to these three. Pros and cons: M-LOK and KEYMOD vs PICATINNY Mil-Std-1913 RAIL This can make or break the decision here. The difference between the Glock Gen 3 trigger and the rest of the triggers is that the Gen 3 has a very hard and stiff wall with a very heavy trigger as well. It’s cheaper, and both the HK VP9 and Glock 17 require you to purchase suppressor-height sights, so that’s a wash financially. The Glock 17, on the other hand, just looks kind of plain. Grip: For starters, the VP9 has a comfortable, ergonomic, and customizable panels that the Glock does not. If you’re a very small individual, you’ll likely have printing issues with these firearms. Now, the Glock 17 Gen 5 texturing is slightly more aggressive. The sights on a Glock is a hit or miss (again, no pun intended) for many. Depending on the model you get, it may or may not have serrations and they’ll work, but they’re not great. It’s somewhere between a hard stiff wall and a rolling break but doesn’t quite fit into either category. Once you reach that wall, you can feel a little bit of pressure build before the trigger breaks. Ordering parts after troubleshooting your VP9 is quite the hassle, to say the least. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. We’ll describe each generation at the wall and lead-up to the break below. The Gen 3 guns have a fairly large grip with no modularity. Yes, I remember! Honestly, the VP9 is a top-notch firearm that offers many features that are comparable if not better than the Glock. Honestly, the VP9 is a top-notch firearm that offers many features that are comparable if not better than the Glock. If you’re looking for a function that comes with a good set of sights, buying a mid-end Glock with Ameriglo sights from the factory is going to be the best value since it’ll be between $80 and $100 less than an HK VP9 before you buy a decent set of sights for the HK VP9. H 4.99 in. The texture on the Glock, again, is going to depend on what generation of gun you have. The HK VP9 comes with two different mag release options: you have the standard HK paddle (which I really like), and then you have the HK VP9-B variant, which is a push-button-style release. I’ve put well over a thousand rounds through the Glock 17 in my career, and about 300-400 rounds in the VP9 by now. Glock components are mass-produced, cheaper than dirt, easy to come by, and everywhere in the US – both factory and aftermarket. The VP9 uses the same steel magazines as the P30. I started out early on in my education with the Glock sights, so I don’t find it too much of a hassle. If your go-to is a grossly outdated Elmo Fudd double-barreled shotgun, then stick with that over whatever new firearm out there that hits the civilian market. Fortunately, I am sufficiently comfortable with the Glock’s grip as is. Lastly, the Gen 5 texturing is much more aggressive, but not so much that it’ll chafe your skin when you’re carrying the gun. Usually, I reserve judgment on any firearm until I go through at least 200 or so rounds to come to a conclusion. Glock vs. HK - Which would you buy; Glock 19, Gen 5 or HK VP9 SK. Thinking of upgrading my Glock 17 gen 4 with the new gen 5 or getting a HK VP9.Was just hoping to get opinions on what is the superior pistol out of the HK VP9 & Glock 17 (any gen) in terms of accuracy and durability? Ironically, it’s Patridge sights, named after E. E. Patridge, a 19th-century American sportsman, was actually designed for greater accuracy through the vertical alignment. So we’ll take a look at the grip, recoil impulse, sights, price, and more so you can decide which gun fits your individual needs.